Gift Cards and Counter Party Risk
Posted 19 Nov 2008
Gift cards are a common gift during the holiday season. Usually stores exchange at a 1:1 ratio. Counter-party risk requires the financial ability to the counter-party to perform the contract. Why anyone buys gift cards surprises me.
Exchanging one asset for a less safe and less liquid and not requiring a risk premium seems awfully stupid. Gift cards function like an unsecured non-interest bearing loan to the retailer (counter-party). At least charge for the counter-party risk. What a deal for the retailer!
Many of these retail institutions are in or near bankruptcy. As the credit contraction continues and economic activity continues grinding to a halt many more victims will be claimed and many retail corpses will litter the malls throughout the nation.
If a company knows they are near failing and still issue gift cards I question the integrity of their management and the applicability of fraudulent conveyance statutes. Anyway, here is a list of retailers, with some preliminary research but not completely verified information, which may prove unreliable counter-parties:
- Circuit City filed Chapter 11 November 10, 2008
- Ann Taylor 117 stores nationwide closing
- Lane Bryant, Fashion Bug, and Catherine's to close 150 stores nationwide
- Eddie Bauer to close stores 27 stores and more after January
- Cache will close some stores
- Talbots closing down specialty stores
- J. Jill closing stores
- Pacific Sunwear closing stores
- GAP closing 85 stores
- Footlocker closing 140 stores more to close after January
- Wickes Furniture closing down
- Levitz closing down remaining stores
- Bombay closing remaining stores
- Zales closing down 82 stores and 105 after January
- Whitehall closing some stores
- Piercing Pagoda closing some or all stores
- Disney closing 98 stores and will close more after January.
- Home Depot closing 15 stores
- Macys to close 9 stores after January
- Linens and Things closing some stores (Update: Linens-N-Things has filed bankruptcy)
- Movie Galley Closing some stores
- Pep Boys Closing 33 stores
- JC Penney closing a number of stores after January
- Ethan Allen closing down 12 stores.
- Wilson Leather closing down some stores
- Sharper Image closing down some stores
- K B Toys closing 356 stores (Updated: KB Toys filed for bankruptcy December 11, 2008)
- Loews to close down some stores
- Dillard's to close some stores
Additionally, keep in mind that any purchases made are also subject to counter-party risk should the product be defective, tortuous, have a warranty, etc.
During this deflationary credit contraction individuals should be decreasing the risk and increasing the liquidity of their assets. They should avoid counter-party risk with retailer gift cards, unsound banks and fiat currency. There are alternatives, like GoldMoney, to the current monetary system. Happy holidays. Please add any other risky counter-party retailers to the comments.
Additionally, big change is coming to America.
Product Review Sites:
There are some product review sites including About Cellular, Geek Cellular, Geek Purses, Watches Head, Jewels File, Hats Avenue.